
Commodity Trading Crash Course 101: From Oil Barrels to Onion Futures
If you cycle from campus towards the Maasboulevard and look across the water, chances are you’ll see a barge chugging past heading inland. It might be carrying grain to a mill in Germany, iron ore for a steel plant along the Ruhr or coal for one of the power plants. Most of us never give these ships a second thought, but they are the most visible part of one of the oldest markets in the world: commodity trading. And Rotterdam happens to be right at the heart of it.
As some of you might already know there are a lot more financial instruments besides stocks. You have for example options, futures, crypto… and commodities. Your morning coffee, the fuel in the bus and the copper in your phone were all traded on the markets before they reached you.
Commodity trading has given us some of the wildest stories in financial history: oil prices dropping below zero, the tulip mania in the 1600’s and a vegetable so heavily manipulated that trading it is still banned in the United States to this day.
In this crash course we will cover what commodities are, how and why they are traded, who the big players are and why Rotterdam sits at the heart of it all. You don’t need prior knowledge, we will go step by step through it all.
What exactly is a commodity?
A commodity is a basic raw material that is the same no matter who has produced it. A barrel of Brent crude from one oil field is as good as a barrel from the next, and a tonne of grain is a tonne of grain. Economists call this a fungible good, units are fully interchangeable, so buyers do not care if it originates from Europe, Asia or America as long as what they are buying meets a set standard. That is what makes commodities so tradeable. Since every unit is the same, you can agree to buy 1000 barrels of oil without ever seeing the actual barrels. Compare that with a share of ASML or a pair of Nikes, where the brand is what you're paying for. With commodities what you buy is exactly what you get.
This wasn’t always the case, as for most of history there was no set standard to meet for commodities and if you wanted to buy a tonne of grain, you would have to go inspect it before knowing if you made a good deal. One of the earliest commodity markets was located in Sumer, modern day Iraq, where people used clay tablets detailing how many goats should be delivered at some date in the future. These were an early form of forward contract. In the early 1600s the Amsterdam exchange became a hub where merchants traded grain, spices and herring, sometimes even before the ships had arrived.
The real breakthrough came in Chicago. In 1848 the Chicago Board of Trade was created as a hub where buyers and sellers could meet to negotiate contracts. In 1865 they revolutionized these contracts by listing the first standardized exchange traded forward contracts, which were called futures contracts. These were centrally cleared contracts, meaning they are secured by payment of margin by clearing members, which made them more reliable to both buyers and sellers.
Why do people trade commodities?
To understand why futures revolutionized the financial markets, picture a wheat farmer near Chicago in the 1860s. He plants his wheat in the spring but only gets paid after the harvest in autumn. If there is a good harvest, chances are that more farmers have a lot of wheat as well, which as we know reduces the price it is traded for. Sometimes the prices even drop so low that the crop is left to rot, instead of being sold. This is where the futures contract makes the difference, it enables the farmer to lock in a price months in advance and know what he would earn whatever happened at harvest time. On the other side a mill or bakery can lock in a price months in advance and have predictable costs regardless of price swings. This is called hedging, and it is still the main reason commodity markets exist. Today it is not just farmers that use commodity markets to hedge: airlines hedge jet fuel, chocolate makers hedge cocoa and energy companies hedge gas. They do this all to protect themselves against price swings that could bankrupt them if you were fully exposed.
But in order for a hedge to work there needs to be a counterpart at the other side of the deal. That is where speculators come in. They do not want the wheat, but are expecting the price of wheat to increase in the future. Speculators often get a bad reputation but they take on the risk that the hedgers want to get rid of, and they keep the market liquid so there is always someone to trade with.
Then there are the physical traders, the big trading houses that actually take delivery of the futures they hold. They make money from arbitrage: buying where something is cheap and selling where it is expensive, storing product bought cheaply when expecting prices to climb or blending it into a higher quality. This is what happens in ports all around the world and also right here in Rotterdam.
Then there are the investors, who add commodities to their portfolio, because commodities often move differently from stocks and tend to hold their value when inflation rises. More on this to follow in the section: How do you get commodities into your portfolio?
How does commodity trading work?
Once you know what a commodity is and why people trade it, the next question is simple: how do you actually buy and sell 10,000 barrels of oil or 500 tonnes of wheat without a fleet of trucks pulling up to your doorstep? There are two main areas: the spot market and the futures market.
The spot market is for immediate delivery. You agree on a price and pay today, and the physical goods change hands right away (or within a couple of days). If a refinery in Rotterdam needs crude oil to keep running next week, they buy on the spot market. It is pretty straightforward: cash for physical goods at the current ‘spot’ price.
Most commodity trading however, happens via futures contracts. A future is a standardized agreement to buy or sell a specific quantity and quality of a commodity at a predetermined price on a specific date in the future. You do not have to wait until the delivery date to do something with them, because these contracts are standardized and traded on major exchanges. In fact, only 2% of all futures contracts ever result in physical delivery.
Instead, traders buy and sell the contracts themselves as prices fluctuate. If you buy December wheat futures at €200 per tonne and a drought hits Europe, pushing the price to €240, you do not have to wait until December to collect a mountain of wheat. You simply sell your contract to someone else before it expires and pocket the €40 difference. If you ‘forget’ to close your contract before expiry, you might actually get a call from a logistics company asking where you would like your truck of corn unloaded. But don’t worry, your broker will send urgent warnings and automatically force-close your position at market price if you fail to act.
For over a century, all of this happened on chaotic exchange floors where traders shouted orders and waved hand signals. In the Netherlands, they came up with a much faster way to sell perishable goods: the Dutch auction clock (veilingklok). At the flower auctions in Aalsmeer, traditional bidding flips on its head. The clock starts at a high price and ticks downward, and the first buyer to hit their button stops the clock and wins the batch. Wait a split second too long for a better price, and the person next to you takes the whole lot. Nowadays, both the trading pits and the physical clock room have mostly moved onto screens, where remote traders and algorithms match supply and demand in milliseconds.
The Big Players & Rotterdam’s Global Role
Most people think of Wall Street names like Goldman Sachs or J.P. Morgan when they hear 'trading.' In physical commodities, even though the biggest firms rarely make the evening news, they move billions of dollars in raw materials every day. Companies like Vitol, Trafigura, Glencore, and Mercuria, alongside agricultural giants like Cargill and Louis Dreyfus, quietly keep global supply chains running. Vitol alone ships over 7 million barrels of oil a day. That is roughly enough to cover the daily energy needs of Germany, France, Spain, and the Netherlands combined.
If these trading houses are the engines of global trade, the Port of Rotterdam is the gearbox. Stretching over 40 kilometers into the North Sea, Europe’s largest port has the deep water needed for massive tankers and sits right at the mouth of the Rhine and Meuse rivers. Cargo unloaded here goes straight onto inland barges, trains, and pipelines heading into Germany, Belgium, and Switzerland. Out toward the Maasvlakte and Europoort, endless rows of storage tanks let traders hold oil and biofuels when prices are low, blend different grades together, and sell when the market turns. Rotterdam barge prices for diesel, fuel oil, and coal are actually used every day as benchmarks by traders from London to Singapore.
Wild Examples & Legendary Stories
Because commodities are tied to weather, wars, harvests, and physical storage limits, the market has seen some pretty bizarre moments over the years.
Tulip Mania (1637)
In the 1630s, rare striped tulips became a status symbol in the Dutch Republic. Soon, merchants weren't just buying bulbs anymore, they were trading windhandel ('wind trade'), early forward contracts promising to buy bulbs still in the ground at sky-high prices. At the peak in early 1637, a single ‘Semper Augustus’ bulb reportedly sold for the price of a canal house in Amsterdam. A few weeks later, buyers didn't show up at an auction in Haarlem, confidence vanished, and prices collapsed by over 90%.
The Onion Ban (1958)
In 1955, two Chicago traders named Sam Siegel and Vincent Kosuga quietly bought up nearly 98% of all available onions in Chicago, along with massive amounts of onion futures. Once they had cornered the supply, they drove prices up and then dumped their entire physical stash onto the market while holding short futures positions. A 50-pound bag of onions crashed from $2.75 to $0.10, which meant the burlap bag itself was worth more than the onions inside. Farmers were wiped out, and Congress passed the Onion Futures Act of 1958 in response. Onions are still the only commodity explicitly banned from US futures exchanges today.
Negative Oil Prices (April 2020)
During the first COVID-19 lockdowns, global fuel demand dried up while oil wells kept pumping. By April 20, 2020, the day before May WTI crude futures expired, storage tanks in Cushing, Oklahoma had completely filled up. Traders still holding expiring contracts realized they were legally required to take physical delivery of oil with nowhere left to store it. In a panic, they literally paid buyers to take the contracts off their hands, sending US crude crashing to -$37.63 per barrel.
'Melk is goed voor elk' (1958)
Even a classic Dutch slogan traces back to commodity surpluses. After World War II, subsidies and modern farming caused European dairy production to explode, leaving governments with massive 'butter mountains' and 'milk lakes.' Rather than letting prices collapse or milk go to waste, the Dutch Dairy Bureau launched 'Melk is goed voor elk' ('Milk is good for everyone') in 1958 to boost domestic demand and get people to drink through the excess supply.
How do you get commodities into your portfolio?
Good news: you don’t need to have a tank to store oil or a warehouse to store wheat in order for you to use commodities in your portfolio. There are several ways to get exposure, each with pros and cons.
Owning the real thing
This is the most literal option of getting exposure to the price swings of the underlying commodity. This is the most practical for precious metals: you can buy gold and silver coins and bars and keep them in a safe (or under your mattress if you trust your roommates). It’s simple but you pay a premium over market price, plus storage and insurance. Just imagine to try doing this with oil.
ETCs and ETFs
For most small investors this is the easiest route. An ETC (exchange-traded commodity) tracks the price of a single commodity like gold, silver or oil. You can often buy this through your broker just like a share. If you want a broader mix there are ETFs that track a whole commodity index, spreading your investment across energy, metals and agriculture at once.
Futures
This is how the profs do it. Futures give you a lot of exposure for a small deposit (margin), which means that the gains and losses are magnified. Contracts have an end date, which means that you have to sell the expiring ones and buy new ones if you want to keep your exposure, which is called rolling them into next month. When future prices are higher than today’s price (contango) every roll over costs you money. That is also why a fund might lose value even when the price of the underlying stays flat.
Commodity stocks
Instead of the commodity itself, you can buy the shares of the company that produces, stores or trades it: oil giants, mining companies or agricultural firms. Their profits usually rise with commodity prices, but you are also taking on company specific risks like management, debt and strikes. So this is an indirect bet, with more risks.
Risk Management: The Golden Rules of the Trade
Commodities move in sharp cycles driven by geopolitics, weather, and supply bottlenecks rather than steady long-term growth. If you decide to try your hand at this market, keep a few practical rules in mind.
Be careful with leverage. Futures and leveraged ETCs only require a small upfront deposit, which means a 5% move in oil or gas can easily wipe out half your position overnight. Also keep an eye on roll costs: check whether an ETF tracks the spot price or rolls futures contracts behind the scenes, because a market in contango can slowly eat away at your returns even when prices stay flat. Finally, keep your position sizes modest. In most portfolios, commodities work best as a 5% to 10% diversifier rather than an all-in bet, and it always pays to look at inventories, seasonal demand, and the US dollar before assuming a commodity is ‘cheap’.
Further Reading, Watching & Following
If you want to dig deeper into this world, pick up ‘The World for Sale’ by Javier Blas and Jack Farchy, which reads like a thriller about how traders like Vitol and Glencore built empires out of oil, metals, and grain. On YouTube, Tom Scott’s video ‘This Clock Was Famous, But The Internet Ruined It’ gives a great behind-the-scenes look at how the Dutch flower auction clock works in Aalsmeer. For regular market updates, Javier Blas’s columns at Bloomberg and CME Group’s education portal are both worth bookmarking.
And if you want to discuss markets and learn alongside fellow students in Rotterdam, check out our Commodity Trading 101 masterclass series with the Erasmus Commodity & Trade Centre (ECTC). The 2026 edition just wrapped up on November 17, so keep an eye on next year’s series, or catch the Trading & Commodity Trading Days in early 2027.

